I'm not sure about the other reviews on here but we had a pretty decent experience at the lucky crab! This may be due to the fact that we were in Phangan at a quiet time but I can't vouch for that. The staff were friendly and attentive and were able to answer all our questions. We ordered the bbq seafood platter to share which was very good and came out in good time. The downside is there wasn't much of an atmosphere but as mentioned this may be due to it being a quiet time. The price was a little higher than we had previously experienced but still not expensive. The platter was 650 baht between us. I would recommend if you're looking for some good bbq seafood on the island.